When someone searches for your type of business in your town, the three results that appear in the map pack get the majority of clicks. Not the website at position one in the organic results. The map pack.
Those three positions are determined almost entirely by your Google Business Profile. How complete it is. How active it is. How many genuine reviews it has. How well the profile data matches what's on your website. And how relevant and authoritative Google considers your business to be for that specific search.
Most businesses in the North West have a Google Business Profile that is doing almost none of this well. Here is what to fix.
The Fundamentals: What Most Profiles Get Wrong
Incomplete Profile Information
Google gives you a lot of fields to fill in. Most businesses fill in the basics — name, address, phone — and stop there. The profiles that rank fill in everything: business description, services, products, opening hours (including holiday hours), attributes (parking, accessibility, payment methods), primary and secondary categories.
Primary category is particularly important. Google uses it heavily in determining which searches you appear for. Most businesses pick a broad category and leave it at that. The businesses dominating local packs have chosen the most specific primary category that accurately describes them, plus several relevant secondary categories.
No Photos or Outdated Photos
Profiles with more than 100 photos get significantly more views than profiles with fewer. Businesses that add new photos regularly outperform those with static or outdated imagery. This is not a correlation — Google's algorithm explicitly rewards active profiles.
The photos should include: the exterior (so people can find you), the interior, products or services in action, and the team. At minimum, aim for 20 high-quality photos at launch and add new ones every week.
Ignoring Reviews
The volume and recency of reviews affects local pack rankings directly. A business with 200 reviews acquired over three years will outperform a business with 200 reviews all from 2021. Recency matters. Consistency matters.
More importantly: responding to reviews matters. Google has confirmed that responding to reviews improves rankings. Most businesses don't respond to anything. Every review — positive or negative — should get a response within 48 hours.
The Local Pack Algorithm: What Actually Drives Rankings
Google's local pack ranking algorithm considers three main factors: relevance, distance, and prominence. Understanding each one tells you where to focus your effort.
Relevance
How well does your business match the search query? This comes from your profile categories, your business description, your services, and the content on your website. A plumber who lists "emergency plumber", "boiler repair", and "bathroom fitting" as services will appear for more specific searches than a plumber who just lists "plumbing".
Distance
How far is the searcher from your business? You can't control this directly, but you can expand your perceived service area by listing specific locations in your service area settings and creating location-specific content on your website.
Prominence
How well-known and trusted is your business? This is the hardest factor to improve quickly, but the highest leverage one. Prominence comes from reviews, from backlinks to your website, from mentions of your business name across the web, and from how established your Google Business Profile is.
The Optimisation Checklist: Do These in Order
| Task | Impact | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Verify ownership of the profile | Critical | 30 mins |
| Set primary and secondary categories correctly | High | 15 mins |
| Write a keyword-rich business description (750 chars) | High | 20 mins |
| Add all services with descriptions and prices | High | 1 hour |
| Upload 20+ high-quality photos | Medium | 2 hours |
| Set up Q&A section with common questions | Medium | 30 mins |
| Create a weekly post schedule | Medium | Ongoing |
| Respond to all existing reviews | High | 1 hour |
| Build a review request process | High | Ongoing |
NAP Consistency: The Silent Ranking Factor
NAP stands for Name, Address, Phone. Google cross-references your profile information against every other mention of your business across the web — directories, social profiles, industry listings, press mentions. If your address appears as "24 High Street" on your website, "24 High St" on Yell, and "Unit 24, High Street" on your Facebook page, Google sees inconsistency. Inconsistency reduces trust.
Do an audit of every place your business is listed online. Standardise the name, address, and phone number exactly. Use exactly the same format everywhere. This is unglamorous work but it has a measurable impact on local rankings.
The Website Connection: Why Your GBP and Site Need to Align
Google doesn't just look at your Business Profile in isolation. It looks at what your website says about you. If your profile says you offer kitchen fitting in Southport but your website doesn't mention Southport, there's a mismatch. If your website has no LocalBusiness schema, Google has to infer your business information rather than reading it directly.
The businesses ranking at the top of local packs almost always have websites with:
- LocalBusiness schema with address, phone, opening hours, and service area
- A dedicated contact page with NAP information that matches the profile exactly
- Location-specific content that references the areas they serve
- Fast load times and good Core Web Vitals scores
The profile and the website need to work together. Optimising one without the other is leaving rankings on the table.
How Long Does It Take?
After a full profile optimisation, most businesses see movement in the local pack within 4 to 8 weeks. Some see it faster for less competitive terms. The key variables are how competitive your category is locally, how many reviews you have relative to the pack, and how well your website supports the profile.
In less competitive towns — which includes most of the North West outside Manchester city centre — a properly optimised profile can move into the local pack within a month. In competitive categories like solicitors or accountants in Liverpool, it takes longer but the commercial value of each position is proportionally higher.
The work is not complex. It is mostly just being thorough about things most businesses haven't bothered with. That's the opportunity.
If you want us to look at your current profile and tell you exactly what's holding it back, the free audit covers this as part of the local SEO assessment.
Related reading: Why Local SEO Is Your New Shop Window, Wigan SEO Guide, SEO Liverpool Guide.

Written by Damian Roche
Founder & CEO, Churchtown Media
20+ years building websites, 15+ years obsessing over SEO. Based in Southport, helping North West businesses turn traffic into revenue with Next.js and data-driven strategies.
More about DamianNeed Help With This Strategy?
We implement these exact strategies for North West businesses. Get a free audit and see where you stand.
Get Your Free AuditNeed help implementing this?
We help Southport businesses turn these strategies into revenue.
Book Strategy Call
